ABOTA
2001 Bryan St.
Suite 3000
Dallas, TX 75201

Phone: (214) 871-7523
Fax: (214) 871-6025

Home > Continuing Education > Courageous Advocacy Award
AMERICAN BOARD OF TRIAL ADVOCATES
COURAGEOUS ADVOCACY AWARD
Summary of Ceremony

AMERICAN BOARD OF TRIAL ADVOCATES
COURAGEOUS ADVOCACY AWARD
PALAZZO VECCHIO-HALL OF THE CINQUECENTO
FLORENCE ITALY

May 17, 1999

  1. PRESIDENT GIRARDI'S INTRODUCTION OF THE MAYOR OF FLORENCE/MAYOR-'S WELCOMING REMARKS

    ABOTA National President, Thomas V. Girardi, welcomed the Sindaco, [the Mayor] of Florence, Dottore Mario Primicerio, to our meeting and introduced him to us. Dr. Primicerio is an internationally renowned scholar and consultant in Physics and his scientific visits have brought him to Austin & Minneapolis and Oxford and Helsinki and to many other important scientific centers around the world. He is a Professor of Applied Mathematics and Physics, University of Firenze. Elected by the people of the Commune di Firenze by a very large margin, he has occupied this Palazzo Vecchio in his service as Mayor for the past four years.

    Dottore Primicerio
    thanked President Girardi, addressed the 400 assembled and welcomed all to this Hall of The CINQUECENTO, the glorious meeting place, since 1302, of the elected of the Republic of Florence-first called the Palazzo della Signoria and now called the Palazzo Vecchio - it is the House of the Mayor of Florence

    Dottore Primicerio presented a most scholarly, deep and moving analysis of the rule of law and of the role of the advocate in guaranteeing the rights of all citizens. Having so honored the dual legal professions of Judge & Lawyer, he then expressed the deep and sincere appreciation of himself, his people of Florence and the people of Italy. He deemed this proclamation in honor of the murdered Judges & Lawyers to be a most important recognition by ABOTA of a terrible time in the History of Italy, a heroic time when they stood up to the terror, a time which must be remembered.

  2. LETTER FROM DOTTORE LAMBERTO DINI, CURRENT MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, FORMER PRIME MINISTER OF ITALY.

    "Mr. President, Thomas V. Girardi, Ladies & Gentleman:

    I am especially proud and happy that the American Board of Trial Advocates has decided to honor with the "Courageous Advocacy Award", the Italian Judges and Advocates who sacrificed their lives in their absolute commitment to justice.

    It is our civic duty to honor and to keep alive the memory of these men and women, as well as to keep alive the values they pursued. Such an example of dedication is to be passed on to future generations.

    I would like to express my personal thanks for the recognition ABOTA has shown with this important award.

    I am sorry not to be able to attend your session due to prior government obligations.

    I would like to extend to you, Mr. President, and to the prestigious members of ABOTA, my best wishes for your work, hoping that your visit to Florence will deepen the co-operation between Judges and Advocates of Italy and the United States.

          With my warmest personal regards,
          /s/ Lamberto Dini
          Il Ministro Degli Affari Esteri
          Roma, 14 maggio 1999"


  3. INTRODUCTION OF REGION OF TUSCANY VICE PRESIDENT, THE HONORABLE MARIALINA MARCUCCI

    Marialina Marcucci has been Vice President of Regione Toscana since April 1998. She also serves as Regional Minister of Communication, Tourism, High Technology, Emigration and Investments in Cultural Affairs. In 1975, she launched Elefante TV and then later went on to become President of Beta Television, the company which owned the Vidoemusic trademark. Videomusic, with its 24 hour per day non stop programming, was the first music television station in Europe and the second in the world. In her position at Beta, she was the key figure in the acquisition of Super Channel, the pan European satellite and cable television station. Since that Company was sold to NBC in 1993, she has focused her energies on public service. A native of Tuscany, her duties as Vice President bring those years of highest level, executive experience to her people of Regione Toscana. The fact that this creative leader has graced us this evening is not only an honor to ABOTA, but is also a clear acknowledgement that the people of Tuscany are sincerely grateful for this important, special recognition and proclamation.

  4. (4) PROCLAMATION OF THE COURAGEOUS ADVOCACY AWARD

    (1) HONORING THE MURDERED MAGISTRATES & ADVOCATES

    The Consulate General of the United States is housed on the Lungarno Amerigo Vespucci, just a block or two from our Hotel Excelsior. In front of that very impressive Palazzo is a statue of Giuseppe Garibaldi, the hero of the Risorgimento, that 19th Century movement which culminated in the unification of Italy, creating the geography of the country as we know it today-bordered by France and the Tyrrhenian Sea to the West, by Switzerland & Germany to the North, by Austria and Yugoslavia and the Adriatic Sea to the East and by the Mediterranean and North Africa to the South.

    Garibaldi was such an inspirational leader. Born in 1807 in the then Italian city of Nice, he joined Giuseppe Mazzini, the Father of the Italian Republic, in the 1830's. When the time came in 1859, he was more than ready. He started with I MILLE, [the thousand], his band of volunteers. Those GARIBALDINI took Sicily and then Calabria and then Naples. For several years in the earliest days of the Republic, this beautiful city of Florence served as the capitol of the new nation. By 1860 the land of the New Republic encompassed all but Venice & Rome.

    Because of his magnificent, inspirational leadership and his military, tactical genius, our President, Abraham Lincoln, invited Giuseppe Garibaldi to head the Union Army in the War Between the States. He graciously declined and instead remained a part of the unification-Venice in 1866 and finally Rome being brought into the fold in 1870. He died at the age of 75 in 1882.

    Inspired by the wisdom of our great President Abraham Lincoln, we, The American Board of Trial Advocates, come to Italy to honor later GARIBALDINI, who gave their lives 100 years after those revolutionary days, who died as martyrs to the rule of law. These murdered Judges and Lawyers served from Turin and Milan in the North to Calabria and Palermo in the South. They were murdered because they were enforcing the law against corruption of all kinds:

    • Against the Omerta of the Mafia in Sicily;
    • Against the corruption of Bank President Calvi & Financier Sindona in the Banco Ambrosiano collapse in Milan;
    • Some were killed for their vigorous prosecution of communist terrorists from the extreme left;
    • Others were murdered for their relentless pursuit of NeoNazi terrorists from the extreme right.

All were killed because they refused to give in to terror even though they knew that their names were at the very top of the list of intended victims. All of them died violent deaths because they stood fast against terror and in absolute, blood spilling, life giving support for the rule of law.

Their deaths ranged from 1971 to 1992 and so we are remembering a quarter century of ultimate professional sacrifice. We ask for a moment of silence as I say each name, as on our Vietnam Memorial in Washington, D.C., in the order in which they died. Please Stand:

MAGISTRATI
Pietro Scaglione Palermo d. 05/05/71
Francesco Coco Genova d. 06/08/76
Vittorio Occorsio Roma d. 07/10/76
Ricardo Palma Roma d. 07/08/78
Girolamo Tartaglione Roma d. 10/10/78
Emilio Alessandri Milano d. 01/29/79
Nicola Giacumbi Salerno d. 03/16/79
Girolamo Minervini Roma d. 03/18/79
Cesare Terranova Palermo d. 07/24/79
Fedele Calvosa Frosinone d. 11/13/79
Mario Amato Roma d. 11/21/79
Guido Galli Milano d. 03/19/80
Gaetano Costa Palermo d. 08/05/80
Bruno Caccia Torino d. 06/26/83
Gian Giacomo Ciaccio Montaldo Trapani d. 01/13/83
Rocco Chinnici Palermo d. 07/29/83
Antonio Saetta [Stefano, his son] Caltanissetta d. 09/26/88
Rosario Livatino Agrigento d. 09/21/90
Antonio Scopelliti Reggio Calabria d. 08/13/91
Giovanni Falcone, Husband Palermo d. 05/23/92
Francesca Morvillo, Wife Palermo d. 05/23/92
Paolo Borsellino Palermo d. 07/20/92
AVVOCATI
Fulvio Croce
Torino d. 04/27/77
Giorgio Ambrosoli Milano d. 07/12/79

Please be seated.

Dottore Mario Cicala, Judge of the City of Rome and Secretary General of The National Association of Magistrates of Justice of Italy, would you please come forward.

[Dottore Cicala received the COURAGEOUS ADVOCACY PROCLAMATION from President Thomas V. Girardi]

Though he does not read or write or understand English, Dottore Cicala demonstrates his deep gratitude and his sincere intention to honor America and ABOTA, by reading his son's English language translation of the remarks which he had carefully prepared in Italian. His son, Dottore Carlo Cicala, who accompanies his father this evening, is a recent graduate of the University of Rome School of Law. He has just started the practice of law while he awaits final licensure and thus we welcome him to our proud profession.

Dottore Cicala, may this proclamation and memorial hang on a wall of honor in the offices of the National Association of Magistrates of Justice which is located in the City of Rome on the Piazza Cavour, the square dedicated to the memory of that other great Risorgimento hero, Camillo de Cavour.

HONORING THE SURVIVING LOVED ONES.

I spoke earlier of Giuseppe Garibaldi and the unification of Italy. That wonderful genius from this Region of Tuscany, from Lucca and Torre del Lago, composer, Giacamo Puccini, recalled those days of glory with his magnificent artistry. His opera, Tosca, is set in the Rome of the Risorgimento, just before the victory over Rome and ultimate unification of all Italy. The beautiful Tosca, who loves the Risorgimento - committed painter, Cavaradosi, sings an aria of exquisite pain, of total despair. About to be defiled by the anti-revolutionary spy, Scarpia, Tosca sings her prayer of utter hopelessness:

  • Vissi D'Arte, Vissi D'Amore [I have lived for art, I have lived for love.] I brought flowers to your altar, O Lord, I have dressed your tabernacle in splendor
  • Perque, Perque, Signor [Why, O Why, O Lord, do you abandon me cosi (like this)?]

    The widows and the children and the grandchildren of these murdered Judges & Advocates certainly have every right to say, Perque, Perque, O Lord - Why him, why her, why us.

    But they have an answer to their Perque - It is in the glory of the deed, in the meaning of the sacrifice. If husband and father and grandfather, if wife and mother and grandmother did not know and love the law, did not stand up to terrorism, then the law, the glory of ancient Rome, La Legge uguale per tutti, [equal justice under law] would have been pulverized, would have collapsed in ruin.

    Seated here today along with Mayor Primicerio & Vice President Marcucci and President Girardi, at this table where the elected of Florence have been sitting for the past 700 years, are the loved ones of one of those heroes whose name was just read, Dottore Guido Galli. May I present to you:

      Signora Bianca Berrizi in Galli, the widow of Dottore Guido Galli,
      Dottoresa Alessandra Galli, Magistrato di Justitia, like her father before her,
      Francesca Spada, age 12, and Laura Spada, age 10, grandaughters of Dottore Guido Galli

    Would the four of you come forward, please, to receive the Proclamation in representation of and on behalf of all of the families and loved ones of all of these martyrs.

    In 1980, at the age of 47, having just been appointed to the highest court, the Magistrati di Cassazione, (the Supreme Court of Italy), Dottore Guido Galli, Judge and Scholar, Professor of Law, was shot and killed by the Brigate Rosse, the Red Brigade. A newspaper photograph was taken of him in his fallen state on the floor in a corridor of the University. Italian Law has the Codex Civile and the Codex Penale. Beside his body lay the open Codex which he had been reading as he walked into his sudden, violent death.

    The first born of Dottore Guido Galli & Bianca Berizzi in Galli, was Alessandra, now Judge Alessandra Galli, who stands here before you this evening. When she was 9 years old, she was a fledgling journalist who conducted an interview of her father. She asked him the Where and the What and the When and the Why of his work. As to the WHERE, He responded to his child/interviewer that he worked sometimes at the Palazzo di Justitia and sometimes at the Office of the Coroner and sometimes at the prison. And to the WHAT, he told her that his job was to make clear what happened by taking evidence and by questioning witnesses. And to the WHEN, he said that he did not have a fixed time, that he sometimes worked through the night. And to the WHY, he said because I love my work, because I can make society safe, because we must not be afraid.

    [ABOTA President, Thomas V. Girardi, now presents the Proclamation to Dottore Galli's widow and to one of his children, Alessandra and to two of his grandchildren, Francesca & Laura Spada]

    This wonderful building is the place of honor for the Sindaco, the Mayor of Firenze. His private office, just outside this room and across the hall, was one of the guest rooms when his house was converted into the 16th Century Palace of the Medicis. The paintings in his chambers are in memory of Pope Clement VII, the second Medici to ascend the Papal throne. Because Clement VII's office took him away from Florence and to Rome, he called upon his trusted advisor and counselor, Francesco Guicciardini to be his eyes and ears here in Florence. Guicciardini is remembered as a great historian, not only of Florence and the Medicis of his time, but also as the author of The History of Italy, the seminal scholarly work which all historians must turn to even today. In the middle of the 1500s he wrote:

      "Past things shed light on future ones; the world was always of a kind. What is and will be, was at some other time; the same things come back, but under different names and colours; not everybody recognizes them, but only he who is wise and considers them diligently."

    To FRANCESCA SPADA and to LAURA SPADA, The American Board of Trial Advocates honors you, you who never knew your Nonno. We say to you that because your grandpa was a martyr to the rule of law in Italy, he was and is a hero to the whole world.

      Non Dimentichiamici - We shall not forget

    May GUIDO GALLI and his heroic colleagues rest in peace and in the knowledge that they and their lives made a difference to us all. May their light be a perpetual light shining upon us all and may they rest in peace and in glory.

 

About | Education | Foundation | Public Events | News | Members Area | Publications | Online Store | Links | Contact | Sitemap

ABOTA | 2001 Bryan St. | Suite 3000 | Dallas, TX 75201 | Phone: (214) 871-7523 | Fax: (214) 871-6025